Source: The Financial Times
This month, artificial intelligence [AI] bots have even joined Santa’s workshop. In short, AI-powered gifts are on the rise – as I know firsthand, having just been given an impressive AI-assisted dictation device.
Meanwhile, retailers such as Walmart are offering AI tools to help stressed holiday shoppers. Think of them as the digital equivalent of a personal elf, offering shortcuts for shopping and gift-giving. And, judging by recent reviews, they seem to be working quite well.
But here lies the paradox: even as AI spreads through our lives – even into Christmas stockings – hostility toward it remains extremely high. Earlier this month, for example, a British government survey found that four in ten people expect AI to bring benefits. Yet three in ten predict significant harms due to “data security breaches”, “the spread of disinformation” and “job displacement”.
Perhaps this is not surprising. The risks are real and have been widely highlighted. Yet, as we enter 2025, it is worth reflecting on three often-overlooked points about the current anthropology of AI, which may help us understand this paradox more constructively.
First, we need to rethink which “A” we are using in “AI” today. Yes, machine-learning systems are “artificial”. Yet bots do not always – or usually – replace our human brains as an alternative to flesh-and-blood cognition. Rather, they usually enable us to act faster and move more efficiently in carrying out tasks. Shopping is just one example.
So perhaps we should reframe AI as “augmented intelligence” or “accelerated intelligence” – or as “agentic intelligence”, to use a term that a recent Nvidia blog calls the “next frontier” of AI. This refers to bots that can act as autonomous agents, carrying out tasks for people according to their instructions. This will be a major theme in 2025. Or, as Google declared when it introduced its latest AI model, Gemini: “The agentic era of AI has arrived.”
However, different cultures see AI differently. Attitudes in developing countries, for example, tend to be much more positive than in developed ones, as James Manyika, co-chair of a UN advisory body on AI and a senior Google executive, recently noted.
Countries such as Japan are also different. In particular, the Japanese public has long shown much more positive feelings toward robots than their Anglophone counterparts. This is now reflected in attitudes toward AI systems as well.
Why is this? One factor is Japan’s labor shortage (and the fact that many Japanese are skeptical about allowing immigrants to fill this gap, making robots easier to accept). Another factor is popular culture. In the second half of the 20th century, while Hollywood films such as The Terminator or 2001: A Space Odyssey spread fear of intelligent machines among Anglophone audiences, the Japanese public was captivated by the Astro Boy saga, which portrayed robots in a positive light.
Its creator, Osamu Tezuka, attributed this influence to the Shinto religion, which does not make strict distinctions between living and non-living things – unlike Judeo-Christian traditions. “The Japanese do not distinguish between humans, as superior beings, and the world around them,” he said previously. “We readily accept robots, along with the wider world around us: insects, rocks – everything is one whole.”
This is reflected in the way companies such as Sony and SoftBank design their AI products today. As one of the essays in Imagining AI notes, these companies try to create “robots with heart” in a way that American consumers might find frightening.
Third, this cultural variability shows that our reactions to AI need not be fixed, but can evolve as technological changes and cross-cultural influences emerge. Consider facial-recognition technologies. In 2017, Ken Anderson, an anthropologist working at Intel, and his colleagues studied Chinese and American consumers’ attitudes toward facial-recognition tools. They found that while Chinese consumers accepted these technologies for everyday tasks, such as making bank payments, American consumers were more reserved.
This difference reflected Americans’ concerns about privacy. But in the same year that the study was published, Apple introduced facial-recognition tools on the iPhone, which were quickly accepted by American consumers. Attitudes changed. The key point is that “cultures” are not closed, static boxes. They are more like slow-moving rivers, with shifting banks, where new streams emerge.
So, whatever 2025 may bring, one thing we can predict is that our attitudes toward AI will continue to change considerably as the technology becomes increasingly normal. This may worry some, but it could also help reframe the technology debate more constructively and focus on ensuring that people control their digital “agents” – not the other way around. Investors today may be rushing toward AI, but they should ask what “A” they want in that AI label. /Telegrafi/







