By Christopher S. Hyland

Every new republic arrives, from time to time, at a crossroads where it must choose between two ways of understanding itself — one that seeks common ground and another that confuses deadlock with principle. Kosovo, a country I have supported for decades, finds itself at precisely such a crossroads this summer.

Three times in just over a year, its citizens have gone to the polls; three times they have ranked Albin Kurti’s Vetëvendosje as the country’s leading political force; and three times the Assembly has failed at the one task these elections were supposed to make possible — securing the two-thirds majority required to elect a President. The head-of-state seat remains vacant; Vjosa Osmani’s term ended in April, and Albulena Haxhiu is now serving as Acting President.

Coalition talks following the June 7 elections — in which Vetëvendosje again came first with about 47% of the vote, but without the majority needed to govern alone — have now broken down. The leader of the Democratic League of Kosovo ended negotiations amid turmoil within his own party. This is not a crisis imposed from outside. To Kosovo’s misfortune, it is a calamity of its own making.

I would venture to say that in this situation the remedy is older than the disagreement itself and that it has a name: Rugovism.

Aristotle argued that happiness is the striving to become something greater than ourselves — a human right and a human duty that asks each of us to develop the gifts given by God in order to become the best version of ourselves. This teaching was passed down through the centuries by way of John Locke and Thomas Jefferson and, in our time, through Ibrahim Rugova, Kosovo’s founding President. He embodied the spirit that I have long seen as the essence of all his politics — the spirit of I, you, and we.

That is: I feel pain for a suffering Kosovo; you feel pain for it, too; and together, we have a duty to ease that suffering and reach the solution that makes this possible. The politician who refuses to take part in a parliamentary session so that a President will not be elected has abandoned this spirit for the easier path — which is almost always the path that fuels division.

Christopher Hyland and Prime Minister Albin Kurti, during one of their meetings, in Pristina.

I met Ibrahim Rugova on March 30, 1992, in a suite at the New York Hilton, accompanied by Avni Spahiu and thanks to the mediation of Jim Xhema. He sat immersed in cigarette smoke, wrapped in a long scarf, and spoke — calmly, as if everything had already been accomplished — of a constitutional future not yet born: an independent Kosovo, heir to ancient Dardania, the birthplace of Rome, which would stand, just as Jefferson and Adams had hoped their new colonies would, as a beacon of hope; a republic governed by the rule of law rather than feudal grievances, mindful of the rights of every citizen, regardless of their background. His mind had been shaped by the liberal arts — history, philosophy, mineralogy, aesthetics — a patient, nuanced mind at ease with paradox. At the door, as we parted, he turned once more and uttered a single word: Dardania. He himself was part of the history he evoked, moving, despite its wounds, toward a fairer and more prosperous future.

Sociologist Dr. Brené Brown has given us a phrase that captures what leadership demands at moments like these — “courage over comfort” — and Rugova chose courage almost every time, even when it was unpopular, even when being misunderstood meant facing opposition. He worked to prevent what could have become a sustained and destructive clash between several militant factions and the Kosovo Liberation Army. When he was elected President, he included his rivals in the governance of Kosovo.

And, perhaps most contentious of all, he sought reconciliation with Serbia — not out of naivety, but because he recognized the centuries of suffering left behind and the even greater suffering that could come if the old pattern of enmity and revenge were allowed to continue. His education had given him what Dr. Brown would call the ability to navigate complexity — situational awareness, the ability to discern patterns, tolerance for nuance and paradox — qualities that are not merely ornaments of a cultivated person, but precisely the tools Kosovo’s current crisis so desperately needs.

The independence that made Kosovo possible was won in the arena of history — by Rugova, by the leadership of the University of Kosovo, by Kosovo’s citizens and brave fighters, by the indispensable diaspora, embodied for me by Jim Xhema and Ekrem Bardha, among many others, by Vehbi Bajrami of the “Illyria” newspaper, as well as by Presidents Bush, father and son, and President Clinton, who did not allow this cause to fade.

President Theodore Roosevelt, in his speech at the Sorbonne on April 23, 1910, expressed his highest regard for “the man who is actually in the arena,” who, even at worst, “fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who know neither victory nor defeat.” Kosovo’s citizens entered that arena and defeated tyranny. It would be truly bitter to see them now, when victory is already theirs, risk a calamity of their own making — not for lack of votes, but for lack of willingness to respect the result.

The political parties, each an essential part of any solution, are now called upon to overcome their hesitations, ambitions, and narrow interests. Here, the 18th-century statesman Edmund Burke continues to teach them: “All government, indeed every human benefit and enjoyment, every virtue, and every prudent act, is founded on compromise and barter.” Kosovo cannot be either secure or protected as long as its politicians refuse this compromise and put their own interests above the national interest — a refusal that continues in part because citizens have yet to hold them accountable. When opposition leaders obstruct the quorum through which the President is elected, they are not simply obstructing a political rival; however unintentionally, they are helping those who wish this new state to fail, and that obstruction entails complicity with the destructive forces at work.

The arithmetic of legitimacy translates easily across the Atlantic. Bill Clinton won the Presidency of the United States in 1992 with just 43 percent of the vote — 4 percent less than Albin Kurti’s Vetëvendosje received this June — and no one in Washington thought that this made his legitimacy questionable. Therefore, every party, and above all the Democratic League of Kosovo — the party Ibrahim Rugova himself founded — must finally step forward, form a government with Kurti, the winner of three consecutive elections, and allow the Assembly to elect the head of state.

For the LDK to block the formation of a government and the election of a President in the name of political advantage is not loyalty to its founder; it is a repudiation of his entire method, which was based on political cooperation for the common good. Ask Ukë Rugova, the President’s son, what his father would do, and he will give you the same answer.

President Ibrahim Rugova (1944-2006)

Because what is taking shape in this corner of the Balkans is something far more hopeful than a quarrel over a seat: it is the possibility of a Kosovo that completes its journey toward the European Union, keeps its sons and daughters in their homeland instead of losing them to emigration, and takes its rightful place, alongside Albania and its neighbors, in a Balkan Community built on constitutional democracy, religious pluralism, and reconciliation. Let the parties set aside their vanities; let the Democratic League honor its founder by governing rather than obstructing; let the Assembly elect the President required by the Constitution; and let Kosovo show once again, as it has before, that its democracy is stronger than the individuals trying to hold it hostage.

On the United States Capitol are engraved the words attributed to King Solomon: “Where there is no vision, the people perish.”

Rugova had that vision. Now it is up to those who claim to carry on his legacy to prove that they still have the courage to put it into practice. Kosovo has entered the arena before. It can enter it again.

Christopher S. Hyland is a veteran diplomatic adviser specializing in Balkan affairs and interfaith dialogue. He served as Deputy National Political Director for Ethnic Communities in Bill Clinton’s 1992 presidential campaign, has championed Kosovo’s sovereignty for more than thirty-five years, and is a member of the Order of Dr. Ibrahim Rugova. He met Ibrahim Rugova in New York in 1992. He is a recipient of the Gandhi Peace Award and the Order of St. Patrick for Peace in Ireland..