By: Ardit Gjinali

The end of 2024—a dramatic election year in various countries across the world’s political map, an election year marked by anxiety, uncertainty, ambiguity and more than dilemmas—not only about the respective election results, but also about the political stability of governments on the national stage for many political actors, both European and beyond the continent in geographical terms, depending on the political implications in an intercontinental context. Endings often carry the dramatic connotations conveyed by the term itself, but “the end of a term” does not always convey drama—the Presidency of the European Union is an example of how an “ending” is a baton passed directly to a beginning, with a philosophy of continuity in the shared vision of a better Europe, more politically present and more effective in decision-making.

The end of 2024 also marks the end of the Hungarian Presidency, held by a member state of the Visegrad Alliance during the period June–December 2024, and the beginning of the Polish Presidency, held by another member state of the Visegrad Alliance during the first six-month period of the coming year, namely January–June 2025. It is worth mentioning that Slovakia, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland are the four countries that make up the Visegrad Alliance—all four are members of the European Union, following the major enlargement of 2004.

Poland will hold the Presidency of the European Union for the second time during the period January–June 2025, following its first time in 2011. The country has experienced a fierce political clash through extreme polarization, also visible in the final election result that brought about a change of government. The country is governed by a reformist coalition government led by Donald Tusk, leader of the Civic Platform, who will lead the Presidency of the European Union in his capacity as Prime Minister of Poland, following the 2023 elections. The same Donald Tusk was also Prime Minister of Poland during 2007–2014, President of the European Council during 2014–2019, and chairman of the European People’s Party during 2019–2022. The Polish Presidency of the European Union will shape its institutional action around three main priorities: energy, defence and security.

Tusk has clearly emphasized, in a powerful political voice—not because of its volume, but because of his personal political stature and that of the country he represents—that the Polish Presidency will be one of effective action. This action is intended to extend beyond Poland’s term, with the Polish term serving as the beginning of a new mindset for Europe. According to Tusk, “Europe cannot remain in a state of survival, but must be in a position to act fully, politically and actively,” and he has continued to repeat, more than once, that “We will make Europe think Polish in many ways.”

Security will be the top priority in all its dimensions, including the internal dimension, namely across the Union’s political landscape in areas such as competition, food quality, essential medicines and a realistic study of a new energy price for businesses and citizens, as well as ensuring security of supply and energy diversification. On the other hand, the external dimension, which extends beyond the Union’s political borders, includes protecting Europe’s borders, cybersecurity, combating disinformation through foreign interference, and expanding the Union’s defence industry as a whole. The defence budget in 2023 was around 279 billion euros, but realizing the vision of a common European air defence will call for an increased, multidimensional commitment. Poland’s ambassador accredited in Tirana, Agnieszka Bartol, would emphasize: “The mindset has changed radically. We are now talking about new funding for defence, which was taboo a few years ago.”

This new funding for defence would enable the Union to take a new direction, with funding on a scale similar to that of the other two global actors, namely the US and China. Continuing in the same vein, Tusk would declare: “Whether it is energy, climate, food, strengthening Europe’s defence capabilities or transatlantic cooperation, policy on the war between Russia and Ukraine—in every area, we will have to overcome traditional divisions and remember that the security of the entire continent depends on us.”

Political relations with Germany and France remain of fundamental importance to a successful Presidency, with the principle of “political balance” at the heart of encouraging the Union’s political proactivity during the Presidency. Despite an unfavourable political period—namely the fall of Chancellor Scholz’s government in Germany following a negative confidence vote in the Bundestag and the early elections to be held in February 2025, as well as political instability in France, where governments have been repeatedly unable to continue because they lack the numbers in the French Parliament—Prime Minister Tusk’s experience will be essential in advancing the Polish agenda in coordination with the EU axis of France and Germany, as a pan-European interest regardless of national political dynamics in France, Germany or Poland.

Tusk’s visits in February 2024 to Berlin and Paris, respectively, remain an example of a new era of cooperation that will positively affect the full implementation of the Polish Presidency of the European Union’s agenda. The visit to Germany took place despite the strong political rhetoric directed against him by the Polish conservative opposition, namely the Law and Justice Party. On the other hand, during French President Macron’s visit to Warsaw in December 2024, his meeting with Prime Minister Tusk confirmed their shared commitment to defending peace and strengthening the instruments that would ensure the further consolidation of European security, with Poland able to be considered a positive example within this vision. The statements by the two leaders, Tusk and Macron, were as follows. Macron would emphasize: “We share a vision: the only possible peace is a lasting peace, which means a peace negotiated by the Ukrainians that will allow them to have a long-term security solution.” Tusk, meanwhile, emphasized: “After our discussions, we see the need for absolute unity in Europe in order to act in favour of peace in Ukraine. Poland is home to the logistics hub, unique of its kind, that serves to transfer aid to Ukraine. We are the ones bearing the burden of securing the EU’s eastern border.”

Beyond discussions and shared commitments to peace, security and greater European proactivity, one polarizing challenge within the European Union during these six months of the Polish Presidency will be the implementation of the trade agreement between the European Union and the Mercosur countries. It was signed by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and the leaders of the Mercosur countries, namely Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay. The agreement is expected to face a lengthy path to implementation, with its main challenges being approval by the European Parliament and overcoming the scepticism of chiefly the two countries with the strongest opposition within the European Union, namely France and Poland. The agreement, and Prime Minister Tusk’s position on it, remain difficult because of the implications that a “Yes” to the agreement would have on Poland’s domestic political scene, particularly with the May 2025 presidential elections and public support among farmers for government policies as a whole in the period ahead. Strong political polarization could also have knock-on effects on broader decision-making in line with the EU’s political position towards other global actors.

The Polish Presidency of the European Union carries positive expectations for encouraging the enlargement process with regard to political actors and countries in the Balkan region that hold candidate status, as well as Ukraine and Moldova. President Duda would emphasize the following during an informal meeting in Krakow with the presidents of several EU member states, namely Italy, Bulgaria, Germany, Croatia, Greece, Estonia, Slovenia, Latvia, Hungary and Slovakia: “First and foremost, we want Ukraine, as well as Moldova and the countries of the Western Balkans, to be admitted to the European Union. We all hope that Georgia will be admitted after the next elections. There should also be a more active role for the United States in its relations with the European Union.”

The current Polish president had earlier, before the US presidential elections held on 5 November 2024, expressed the need to hold two summits—EU-US and EU-Ukraine—during the six-month period of the Polish Presidency of the European Union. President Duda emphasized: “We should organize two European summits in Poland to highlight the most important elements of Europe’s development for the future.” He continued: “The meeting between the EU and Ukraine should be dedicated to rebuilding the country attacked by Russia.”

President Duda’s statement expresses a vision for encouraging and strengthening the transatlantic alliance. The Polish president is a vocal political ally of US President-elect Trump, and is considered one of the possible mediators in any potential complex negotiating situation between the European Union and the US over the next four years, if President Duda is confirmed for a new term in the May 2025 presidential elections to be held in Poland. Despite the extreme polarization in national political life, the country experiences important political consensus on major world events, notably its condemnation of Russia for its attack on Ukraine, as well as its further encouragement of the European Union’s enlargement, namely to countries in the Balkans, and to Ukraine and Moldova.

Shared positions in support of a consolidated European alliance will encourage joint institutional commitment to a successful EU Presidency, despite the deep political differences between President Duda and Prime Minister Tusk. A successful Presidency would raise Poland’s reputation in the international arena. However, Poland’s presidential elections, scheduled for 2025, in which the main candidates are expected to be the current president, Duda, and Warsaw Mayor Rafał Trzaskowski, a representative of Prime Minister Tusk’s party, are also expected to turn the European Union Presidency into a campaign issue. The campaign is expected to bring renewed polarization, given the different nature of presidential elections compared with parliamentary elections.

Tusk’s vision and long experience in European Union institutions, combined with President Duda’s proactivity and his special relationship with US President-elect Trump, could lead to a very successful Polish Presidency and a model for each Presidency in the following six-month periods. But the question remains how far the two Polish leaders will overcome divisions at the national level in the interests of a successful Presidency, setting aside successes or shortcomings in parts of the Presidency rather than viewing them through the lens of political rivalry at the national level.

Beyond the positive or constraining aspects outlined chronologically above, Poland’s political and national cohesion in response to Russian aggression in Ukraine will encourage strong political action by the Polish Presidency to transform the European Union into a vocal and active actor on the world political stage. Political action would be a sound foundation for Europe in the coming decade: a global actor that should shape world developments in coordination with the US in light of possible global polarization resulting from the formation of alternative groupings of other global actors.

Polish national interest will transcend differences in national politics, and each of Poland’s political actors will contribute to a successful EU Presidency at a time of global political challenges. A successful Presidency would strengthen Poland’s political reputation in the international arena and turn the Polish Presidency into a guiding model at the end of the 20th anniversary of the EU’s major enlargement. Poland is a successful example of enlargement in historical and economic terms, and in its political positioning in support of the Western and transatlantic alliance as well.