By: Arian Galdini

Stupidity is more dangerous than evil. Evil is easy to identify and fight; stupidity, not so much. The saying “arguing with a fool is like playing chess with a pigeon” means that trying to use logic and reason in an argument with someone who is not willing to listen or consider different perspectives and possibilities is futile, pointless, exhausting, and hurtful. In the analogy, the pigeon will knock over and try to eat the chess pieces, strut around proudly, and declare itself the winner, no matter how well you play. The moral of the story is to save your energy for more productive and meaningful arguments. Mark Twain has a pithy saying of his own about arguing with fools: “Never argue with a fool. He will drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.” All of the above emphasizes an important truth: it is not always worth arguing about everything, especially when faced with stubbornness and a lack of reason.

When something or someone is evil, we can take steps to fight it. But with stupidity, this is much more difficult. Dietrich Bonhoeffer argues that stupidity is more dangerous than evil because it can be manipulated and used by evil. He also says that stupidity often goes hand in hand with power—in other words, being in power means surrendering one’s individual critical faculties. The metaphor of arguing with a fool as playing chess with a pigeon is humorous, but also disturbing. Although we do not always admit it, we all have people in our lives whom we consider “a little awkward”—not about everything, but certainly about some things. Most of the time, we take it in stride. After all, stupidity can also be entertaining. When a friend of ours asks in all seriousness, “What was Hitler’s last name?”, we laugh. When my little one realized just last month that Santa’s reindeer are real animals, it was simply comical. Such things become part of everyday humor. But stupidity also has a dark side. For the theologian and philosopher Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the foolish person is often more dangerous than the wicked one.

In comic books or action movies, evil is clearly recognizable. The villains are the ones who wear dark clothes, kill for no clear reason, and laugh maniacally over their diabolical plans. In real life, too, we know how to identify the wicked—dictators who violate human rights, serial killers, or violent criminals. But according to Bonhoeffer, they are not the greatest threat, because they are familiar and recognizable. Once evil is recognized, the world of good can unite to fight it. As Bonhoeffer explains: “Evil can be protested against, it can be exposed and, if necessary, stopped by force. Evil always carries within itself the seed of its own destruction.” But stupidity is an entirely different problem. We cannot easily fight stupidity for two main reasons. First, as a society, we are much more tolerant of it. Unlike evil, stupidity is not seen as a vice that should be condemned. We do not harshly criticize others for their ignorance. Second, the foolish person is an “elusive” opponent. You cannot defeat them with arguments or logic. On the contrary, when confronted with indisputable facts, they explode and react aggressively.

Bonhoeffer puts it this way: “Neither protests nor the use of force have any impact, reasons fall on deaf ears, facts that contradict their prejudices are simply not accepted—at such moments the foolish person even becomes critical. And when the facts are indisputable, they are simply brushed aside as irrelevant, as incidental. In all this, the foolish person, unlike the wicked one, is completely self-satisfied and, because they are easily irritated, becomes dangerous by going on the attack.” With great power comes great stupidity. Like evil, stupidity poses no threat as long as it has no power. We laugh at harmless things, such as a small child’s ignorance about reindeer. This does me no harm. That is also why it is funny. The real problem with stupidity is that it often goes hand in hand with power. Bonhoeffer writes: “On closer observation, it becomes clear that every powerful upsurge of power in the public sphere, whether political or religious, infects a large part of humanity with stupidity.” This happens in two ways. First, stupidity does not prevent you from holding power.

History and politics are full of examples of uneducated or unqualified people who have reached the top (and of intelligent people who have been excluded or eliminated). Second, the nature of power requires individuals to surrender some of their most important faculties for intelligent thought—faculties such as independence, critical thinking, and reflection. Bonhoeffer argues that the more a person becomes part of the power structure, the less of an individual they remain. A charismatic and intelligent outsider, full of reasonable ideas, turns into an idiot as soon as they take office. It is as if “slogans, catchwords, and the like… have taken possession of his soul. He is under a spell, blinded, manipulated, and abused in his very being.” Power turns people into automatons. Intelligent and critical thinkers turn into individuals who recite prearranged phrases. They choose to smile instead of think. When people join a political party, it seems that most prefer to follow the crowd rather than think independently. Power sucks the intelligence out of the individual, turning them into an animated mannequin.

Bonhoeffer argues that stupidity should be regarded as worse than evil. Stupidity has far greater potential to damage our lives. An idiot in power does more harm than a group of unscrupulous schemers. When there is evil, we know where we stand. We know how to take a stand against the most corrupt, oppressive, and sadistic. But stupidity is much harder to eradicate. That is why it is such a dangerous weapon. Because evil people find it difficult to take power, they need foolish people to do their work for them. Like sheep in a pasture, a foolish person can be led, manipulated, and used for anything. Evil is a master puppeteer, and nothing pleases it more than the feeble-minded puppets who make it possible—whether they are individuals among the people or within the corridors of power. The lesson from Bonhoeffer is this: Laugh at awkward and harmless moments when you are among friends, but become angry and concerned when stupidity takes the reins. /“Panorama” newspaper/