The current debate over the decree dissolving the Assembly and the process of electing the President essentially places the Constitutional Court before two possible interpretive scenarios.
The first scenario is for the Court to uphold the presidential decree dissolving the Assembly, as a result of the failure to elect the President under Article 86.2 of the Constitution. In this case, the Court would apply the classic principle of direct interpretation of the constitutional provision: the provision is read and applied according to its text and clear deadlines. Such a ruling would preserve the standard of respecting the letter of the Constitution and strengthen legal certainty in the constitutional order.
Constitutional deadlines are not arbitrary. They are set to create clarity, prevent political delays, and require institutions to reach political agreements within a reasonable time. In this sense, if the President is not elected within the constitutional deadlines, the constitutional mechanism leading to the dissolution of the Assembly and new elections is activated.
The second scenario is for the Court to choose an indirect or more flexible interpretation, not relying directly on the constitutional provision, but arguing that even if the deadline for electing the President has passed, there is nevertheless a 60-day period during which the process can continue.
Such an interpretation could be justified by the argument that it would avert an immediate political crisis. But this approach would open the door to a much bigger problem: the creation of a dangerous constitutional precedent.
If constitutional deadlines are relativized once, they can always be relativized. This would mean that every future process for electing the President could be extended beyond the limits set by the Constitution. Instead of resolving a momentary political crisis, a long-term and structural constitutional crisis could be created.
Therefore, constitutional deadlines must remain as they are set out in the Constitution. The Court must not create a precedent that weakens the constitutional provision by attempting to resolve a momentary political crisis through an interpretation that could produce ongoing crises in the future.
Essentially, the current problem is not constitutional. The Constitution is clear. The crisis is political. The lack of willingness to cooperate and compromise politically is what is producing, and will continue to produce, the crisis.
P.S. Even if the Court were to decide to give the process of electing the President an additional 60 days, the real likelihood is that the country will end up holding elections anyway. The nomination process has already closed and the voting process has begun. Procedurally, the scope for new alternatives is very limited; in practice, there is no other way.







