In its judgment of 4 November 2026, the Administrative Court fully upheld Visar Misini’s statement of claim as well-founded, annulling as unlawful the decision of the Independent Oversight Board for the Civil Service of Kosovo (IOBCSK), dated 7 April 2025.
With this judgment, the Court upheld the notice of the final list of successful candidates, issued on 20 December 2024 by the Human Resources Management Unit of the Municipality of Viti.
The Court ordered the Municipality of Viti to appoint Misini to the position of Civil Status Officer, pursuant to the public recruitment process of 8 November 2024, within 15 days of the judgment becoming final, under threat of compulsory enforcement. According to the judgment, the Court’s decision replaces the annulled administrative acts and is binding.
In its reasoning, the Court found that Misini had met the recruitment criteria. He had passed the preliminary screening, written test and oral interview, scoring a total of 87.2 points and ranking first on the final list of candidates.
However, after he was declared the winner, the Mayor of the Municipality of Viti annulled the public recruitment process. In the decision challenged in these court proceedings, the IOBCSK annulled the mayor’s decision as unlawful, but also annulled the recruitment process, reasoning that Misini had not met the criterion of one year of work experience after graduation.
The Administrative Court found that this conclusion by the IOBCSK was incorrect. According to the case file, Misini completed his studies on 4 August 2023 and, after graduating, entered into an employment contract with GLOB AUDIT SH.P.K., from 2 October 2023 to 28 February 2025, as an accountant. According to the judgment, this work experience was also confirmed by the Pension Trust statement for the relevant period.
The Court found that even if work experience after graduation was required, Misini had met this criterion. Moreover, the public recruitment notice required only “one year of work experience,” without specifying whether the experience had to be gained before or after graduation.
In support of his claim, Misini had also submitted examples of other recruitment notices issued by the same municipality, in which no distinction had been made between work experience before and after graduation.
According to the judgment, the IOBCSK had incorrectly assessed the facts and misapplied substantive law, thereby violating the plaintiff’s rights. The Court stressed that the recruitment procedures had been conducted in accordance with Law No. 08/L-197 on Public Officials and Regulation (GRK) No. 15/2023 on the Procedure for Admission to the Civil Service.
The Administrative Court held the main hearing on 7 October 2026, in the presence of the plaintiff’s representative, lawyer Sherif Sherifi, and in the absence of the representatives of the defendants.
On the basis of these findings and in accordance with Article 60 of the Law on Administrative Disputes, the Court ruled as set out in the operative part of the judgment.
For the reasons stated above, the judge in the case, Rexhep Bllaca, in accordance with the provisions of Article 60 of the LAD, ruled as set out in the operative part of this judgment.
Separately, Misini had filed a lawsuit against the IOBCSK and the Municipality of Viti, seeking resolution of the matter concerning the failure to sign the appointment act for the position of Civil Status Officer, despite his having been declared the winner of the public recruitment process.
On 3 February 2025, he filed an appeal with the IOBCSK, claiming that the Mayor of the Municipality of Viti had not signed his employment contract after the recruitment results were announced. On 19 March 2025, the IOBCSK informed him that the deadline for making a decision had been extended by ten working days. According to the lawsuit, even after this extension, Misini received no response or decision within the deadline.
In the lawsuit, he claimed that the lack of a response constituted administrative silence under the Law on General Administrative Procedure.
According to his claims, after the recruitment process had concluded and the results had been announced, the Human Resources Management Unit had prepared the contract and forwarded it to the Mayor of the Municipality for signature. However, the latter had refused to sign it, reasoning that he had annulled the recruitment process, without notifying the candidate of this decision in advance.
Misini claimed that the annulment of the recruitment process was contrary to the Law on Public Officials and the Regulation on the Procedure for Admission to the Civil Service, since, according to him, responsibility for the recruitment procedure lay with the Human Resources Management Unit, which had identified no procedural violations.
For its part, the Municipality of Viti contested the statement of claim, deeming it unsupported by evidence and law. In its response to the lawsuit, the Municipality argued that the request for a finding of administrative silence was unreasonable, since the IOBCSK had already issued a decision on the matter.
The Municipality also argued that it lacked passive standing in this case, since the proceedings had been transferred to the IOBCSK, which had ruled on the appeal. According to the Municipality, the recruitment process had been annulled because Misini did not meet the required criteria.
The Municipality also disputed the claims of discrimination, arguing that the recruitment process had been annulled because the legal criteria had not been met, and not for any reason prohibited by the Law on Protection from Discrimination. For this reason, it proposed that the Court dismiss the lawsuit as inadmissible or reject it as unfounded.
In its response to the lawsuit, the IOBCSK also defended the challenged decision, arguing that Misini had not met the work-experience-after-graduation criterion. The Board asked the Court to reject the lawsuit as unfounded and uphold the legality of its decision./BetimipërDrejtësi/







