Ismail SYLA

PARADOXES OF THE NARRATIVE

On April 3, 2025, it will be two years since the trial began against four figures of the Kosovo Liberation Army: Hashim Thaçi, prime minister and president of Kosovo, Kadri Veseli, speaker of the Kosovo Assembly, Rexhep Selimi, former inspector general of the KLA, and Jakup Krasniqi, speaker of the Kosovo Assembly.

On the first day, when the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office presented its incriminating opening statement, it was laughable what they claimed as the basis for their arguments against the accused. There was no unexpected bombshell, nor any surprise about the scale of the “crimes” committed by the accused. With a volume previously unimaginable, the indictment claimed to be based on millions of pages of “evidence,” according to the principle that such a quantity was expected to produce arguments for guilt.

The indictment’s narrative contained so many inconsistencies that they could be identified even by people with no specialist training. The most paradoxical claim was that KLA military operations continued even after June 12, 1999. Another paradox was the impression conveyed by the narrative that the KLA’s primary aim was supposedly to fight the Democratic League of Kosovo, which sought a dominant monopoly over public life in Kosovo. And the height of all the paradoxes, according to the 45-page narrative, was the exclusion of the presence of the violent Serbian administration in Kosovo, the systematic killings of Albanians, their programmatic expulsion from Kosovo, mass crimes, massacres, and genocide against the unarmed population.

THE COURSE OF WITNESSES For two years, hundreds of prosecution witnesses have paraded through this court. Public opinion has been left in the dark about many segments of the testimony, because a large percentage of witnesses were censored, with hearings closed or moved into private sessions. Of all the witnesses we saw during open hearings, not a single fact emerged anywhere about an individual crime committed by one or another of the four accused.

Within the famous (notoriously infamous) abbreviation JCE (Joint Criminal Enterprise) and the hierarchical structure, the chain of command, the prosecution is trying to create two legal paradigms on the basis of which to convict the accused of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Even Carla del Ponte, the former prosecutor of the Hague Tribunal for crimes in the former Yugoslavia, expressed surprise at the burden placed on the four accused. Two high-profile witnesses, Fred Abrahams and Shaun Burns, gave their testimony under oath.

The Western sense of integrity in cases of testimony under oath is admirable. The first, Mr. Abrahams, honestly acknowledged that in his report he had used official Serbian sources and assessments concerning the KLA, and that instead of stating “KLA crimes,” he should have said “allegations of crimes…” The other witness, the American Burns, who had his own legal representative, explained his findings from the field and his contact with the accused during 1998/99 in the most proper manner, saying that they represented the most rational, reasonable, and moderate wing of the KLA.

According to him, the KLA General Staff was more like a “Ministry of Foreign Affairs” than a genuine military structure, because it had neither the human resources nor the professional training of regular armies.

One aspect of the Special Prosecutor’s openly hostile stance was also reflected in its rejection of testimony from high-ranking world figures who would have presented exculpatory evidence for the accused. Thus, in accordance with the biological laws of life, before it was the defense witnesses’ turn, former U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright passed away.

Likewise, the famous British General Michael Jackson died before he could give his testimony. In the parade of witnesses, it is not worth mentioning ridiculous cases, such as the one whose entire resentment toward the KLA was linked to a heifer, regardless of his life story. WITNESSES WITH TWO HATS This Special Prosecutor’s Office has used a cunning tactic with regard to most of the Kosovo Liberation Army’s leaders.

Two hats for one person. The person it summons as a witness (the first hat) and that same person as a suspect (the second hat). This trap yielded results in several cases. First, it forced respected commanders, famous during the glorious period of the Kosovo Liberation Army, to be prosecution witnesses. This position is not without discomfort.

Second, it placed the suspect’s hat on each of them, or, more precisely, the hot lid—the possibility of being indicted and consequently imprisoned. The greatest trick with the suspect-witnesses occurred when the judges supposedly guaranteed that their suspect status would be lifted, that is, that they would be released from the possibility of indictment and arrest. In fact, they were released from the “suspect” position, but the parts of their earlier statements that produced arguments for the guilt of the four accused remained in court.

Their “suspect” status prevented them, during the hearings, from dismantling every nuance, every characterization, and every ambiguity in statements made at different times, in different proceedings, whether before UNMIK investigators, the Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, EULEX, or local courts. It is well known that many trials took place in Kosovo after the war.

All of them were unjust, fabricated, and a priori hostile toward every member of the KLA. There were cases when, for example, witnesses with good intentions, wishing to protect a zone commander, shifted responsibility onto members of the KLA General Staff, believing that they enjoyed greater immunity and were not at risk of imprisonment. The appearance before the Kosovo Specialist Chambers offered an opportunity for this paradox to be properly explained by the suspect-witnesses. But, unfortunately, in most cases it was not explained. The double hat caused confusion precisely among those leaders, commanders, and military personnel who had faced death during the war, confronting the state with the greatest military power in the Balkans.

INSTITUTIONAL ABANDONMENT A separate tragic segment throughout these four years of imprisonment of Kosovo’s state-building figures, and throughout these two years of trial proceedings, has been institutional indifference. The three people in key positions in the Republic of Kosovo—the president, the prime minister, and, in part, the speaker of the Assembly—are not “moon-inside” (friendly) but rather “moon-outside” (hostile) toward the accused.

Neither in the Assembly, nor in international forums, nor at the Security Council, nor in diplomatic contacts did the leaders of the main institutions raise their voices with the responsibility required. There was no institutional response when the Dick Marty Report came out, when dozens of flaws were identified, or as numerous rights violations and classic, continuing discrimination against Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Jakup Krasniqi, and Rexhep Selimi have been taking place. With this stance, the heads of Kosovo’s institutions seem to accept the conviction of the KLA leaders, with a sense of satisfaction that their political legacy will be destroyed.

And that legacy is, first, the just and victorious war of the most successful political-military organization of the 20th century, the KLA’s war. Second, it is the declaration of the independence of the state of Kosovo. These institutions never asked the president of this court, Ekaterina Trendafilova, to report to the Kosovo Assembly. This president cannot find a prison for Sali Mustafa anywhere in Europe, because, as a convicted person, he would have to be removed from The Hague.

Of course, Europe has intelligent lawyers, and as a result, they do not recognize the Specialist Chambers Court or those convicted by it.

AT THE VERY END Twenty-six years after Kosovo’s liberation was completed, in the light of the war in Ukraine, the one in Gaza, and the realignment of the new world order, to hold a trial seeking to classify as war crimes and crimes against humanity phone calls from Kosovo to Switzerland with members of the LPK, wearing the KLA uniform, writing communiqués, and other trivial details; and, after 26 years of freedom and 17 years of Kosovo’s independence, to keep behind bars people with the most pro-Western, pro-American, and pro-democratic political profile, is nothing other than a historical injustice against a nation small in number but great in its efforts, ambitions, dreams, and projects for development, democracy, and integration into Euro-Atlantic institutions.

Pristina, March 29, 2025